Your Insurance Estimate Seems Too Low. Now What?
When the insurer's estimate is lower than a contractor's proposal, the first question is not simply who has the larger number. It is whether both documents describe the same damage and the same repair work. A useful review starts with the scope, then looks at quantities, materials, pricing, and payment adjustments.
For Residential and commercial property owners
Know which number you are reviewing
Ask for the complete itemized estimate, not just a payment letter. Check whether the figure you are comparing is replacement cost, actual cash value, or a payment after the deductible. Depreciation, prior payments, and limits can make an estimate total and a check amount different.
Keep the estimate version, date shown on the insurer's document, and accompanying correspondence. If you do not understand a deduction, ask for its calculation and policy basis in writing.
Match the documented damage to the scope
Walk through the property only where safe, using photographs and professional observations as support. Is each affected room, exterior area, or building component identified? Does the proposed work reflect what was damaged? A stain, a damaged assembly, and hidden damage discovered during authorized work may require different documentation.
You might find an omitted area, an incorrect quantity, or a disagreement about what is related to the loss. Record the issue precisely. Do not assume all nearby deterioration is caused by the covered event. If cause or repair requirements need expert evaluation, use an appropriately qualified professional.
Check measurements, materials, and repair methods
Compare like with like. Differences can come from square footage, material grade, labor tasks, removal and disposal, access requirements, or the method proposed. Ask the contractor to explain why a particular repair is necessary and to identify supporting photographs, measurements, or applicable requirements.
For example, if one estimate includes only replacing damaged flooring and another includes removal and preparation of an affected underlayment, the difference needs an explanation of the actual conditions and work. A higher total alone does not demonstrate that each additional item is covered or necessary.
Build a specific written comparison
Make a short list of discrepancies. For each one, identify:
- The affected area or estimate line item.
- What you believe is missing or incorrect.
- The proposed quantity, material, or repair task.
- Supporting photographs, measurements, invoices, or professional explanations.
- The question you want the insurer to answer.
Ask for itemized contractor proposals. A one-line bid may be harder to compare than a document that separates areas, labor, materials, and related costs. Keep mitigation and emergency repair invoices as well as permanent repair estimates.
Understand a supplemental request
A supplement generally asks the insurer to consider additional or revised information. It may involve newly identified damage, corrected quantities, a revised scope, or documented expenses. It is not automatic approval of a contractor's entire proposal.
Follow the insurer's submission process and applicable policy requirements. Include the supporting documents, state what you are requesting, and retain confirmation of receipt. Ask whether another inspection is needed and what additional information is required. Keep track of policy deadlines during the discussion; a pending request does not necessarily extend them.
Know when the issue goes beyond an estimate
A disagreement may concern the price or extent of repairs, but it may also involve cause, coverage, exclusions, or duties under the policy. Those are different questions. A policy's appraisal provision may address certain amount-of-loss disagreements, but it does not necessarily resolve coverage disputes. The appropriate options depend on the policy and circumstances, and legal questions may require an attorney.
Not every estimate can be increased. Some differences are supported by the existing scope or policy, and additional documentation does not guarantee more payment. The goal is a clear, supported review rather than an assumption about the outcome.
Get help with the review if you need it
CPA reviews claim documentation, investigates the loss, and supports appropriate claim presentations within the scope of public adjusting services. See how our process works or find your current claim situation.
If you have the insurer's estimate, a contractor proposal, and questions about the difference, share what you have. We can discuss whether representation may be appropriate for your Georgia property claim. Discuss your claim.
This resource is general education, not advice about a specific claim or legal advice. Coverage, duties, valuation, and deadlines depend on your policy, applicable law, and circumstances. CPA provides public adjusting services in Georgia.
